Okay, I mean to title this post as “I have a hypothesis” but I figured that a random non-sensible title would attract more attention.
I am an avid user of common phrases and often do not take the time to think about what the individual words that make up the phrases truly mean. “I have a theory” is one such phrase that I would use when there is something I wish to test. The focus of this phrase is the word “theory”, and when given some thought, the word doesn't make much sense when used in this manner.
Our textbook, New Keywords, defines a theory as an hypothesis that has been confirmed by experiment. It also describes a theory to hold some sort of conformed acceptance and technical authority. During class, we've discussed that a criteria for being a theory is having an opposing side of skepticism. When the phrase “I have a theory” is used, the word “theory” often doesn't hold any confirmation, authority, nor the existence of an opposing resistance. A more accurate way of stating the phrase would be “I have a hypothesis”.
This lead me to think about common phrases I use on a regular basis. One thing I commonly say is “can you open the lights?” with the intention of asking someone to turn the lights on. The grammatical misuse of the word “open” is obvious here, though the intended meaning is still easily understood. As an experiment, I tried to go through Thursday without misusing any words in my casual speech. This experiment was short lived after I stubbed my toe on my friend's bed after waking up. “Son of a bitch that hurt!” I exclaimed, and the misuse of several words followed immediately after. Though grammatically incorrect, the statement I made is generally understood to express the extent of my pain through colorful vocabulary.
After extensive pondering on this topic, I've come to the conclusion that these words are not misused as long as the public accepts and understands the meaning of them when used in such a manner. It seems almost unnecessary to force every word to follow its Oxford dictionary definition strictly. Perhaps words can be even be defined through their common use. As long as a certain use of a word in a phrase is accepted by society, then it should be grammatically allowed. That's my theory anyways.
Finals week...
14 years ago